Comparative Analysis of Cost Efficiency in Smallholder and Large-Scale Agricultural Cooperatives

Authors

Abstract

Agricultural cooperatives operate across a spectrum of sizes, from smallholder-based organizations serving dozens of farmers to large-scale enterprises managing thousands of members. The relationship between cooperative size and cost efficiency has profound implications for rural development policy, cooperative governance, and the economic sustainability of smallholder agriculture. This comprehensive literature review synthesizes recent empirical evidence on the comparative cost efficiency of smallholder versus large-scale agricultural cooperatives, drawing exclusively on peer-reviewed literature published between 2019 and 2026. The review critically examines theoretical frameworks explaining scale economies in cooperative organizations, evaluates methodological approaches employed in empirical studies, and synthesizes findings across diverse geographical contexts including Ethiopia, China, Türkiye, Spain, and Papua New Guinea. The analysis reveals that while large-scale cooperatives consistently demonstrate cost advantages through economies of scale, the relationship between size and efficiency is more complex than simple linear models suggest. Smallholder cooperatives exhibit distinct advantages in allocative efficiency, member engagement, and social value creation that may offset their cost disadvantages. Furthermore, the evidence indicates an inverted U shaped relationship between cooperative size and efficiency, with optimal scale varying by sector, institutional context, and governance quality. This review identifies critical gaps in longitudinal research, standardized measurement frameworks, and investigation of the mechanisms through which scale affects cost efficiency, providing actionable recommendations for cooperative practitioners, policymakers, and future researchers.

Keywords

Agricultural cooperatives, cost efficiency, economies of scale, smallholder farmers, cooperative size, technical efficiency, scale economies

DOI

10.0000/wijamssae.v1i1.1

References

Altman, M., Altman, H., Odhuno, F. O., & Lamontagne, L. (2025). How economies of scale
through co-operatives contribute to the economic sustainability of family controlled farms:
Evidence from coffee farmers’ co-operatives in Papua New Guinea. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Bai, H., Qiao, D., & Wang, Z. (2025). Study on the operational efficiency and influencing factors
of farmers' professional cooperatives in Gansu under the background of rural revitalization.
Agricultural Economy, (2), 97–98.
Chen, Y., Zhang, L., & Wang, X. (2025). The impact of cooperatives on livestock production
efficiency in China. Rangeland Ecology & Management, 102, 60–70.
Gezahegn, T. W., Van Passel, S., Berhanu, T., D'Haese, M., & Maertens, M. (2019). Big is
efficient: Evidence from agricultural cooperatives in Ethiopia. Agricultural Economics, 50(5),
555–566.
Grashuis, J., & Cook, M. L. (2021). Members of cooperatives: More heterogeneous, less
satisfied? International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, 24(5), 813–825.
Key, N. (2019). Estimating multiproduct and product‐specific scale economies for agricultural
cooperatives. Agricultural Economics, 50(5), 567–578.
Mangan, A., & Ward, A. M. (2024). Cooperative resilience: Toward a heuristic model of
collective action in a crisis. Financial Accountability and Management, 40(3), 308–325.
Mangoejane, T. P., & Christian, M. (2025). An entrepreneurship framework for improved
productivity and financial performance of primary agricultural cooperatives in North West
Province. South African Society of Agricultural Extension.
Meliá-Martí, E., Mozas-Moral, A., Bernal-Jurado, E., & Fernández-Uclés, D. (2024). Global
efficiency and profitability: Cooperatives as social innovation agents vs. joint stock
companies in the agri-food sector. Journal of Innovation & Knowledge, 9(3), 100537.
Oufkiri, M., & Elkorchi, A. (2025). Agricultural cooperative performance measurement: A
multidimensional framework for economic and social value creation. In Proceedings of the
International Conference on Multidisciplinary Research in Management and Economics (ICMRME 2025)
(pp. 598–606). Atlantis Press.
Swe, Y. L. W., & Lee, J. Y. (2025). Impact of agricultural cooperative membership on technical
efficiency, income, and costs of coffee farmers in Myanmar. Korean Journal of International
Agriculture, 37(1), 12–26.
Yercan, M., & Malkoc, F. (2025). How does cooperative membership affect farm efficiency? A
case study of dairy farms in Izmir, Türkiye. New Medit, 24(1).